Commentary: Right to work and promises yet to be kept

By John Krull 

INDIANAPOLIS – When Indiana Republicans started their push to ram so-called right-to-work legislation through the Indiana General Assembly nearly three years ago, they said that the measure would rain many blessings down on the Hoosier state.

Commentary button in JPG - no shadowThe GOP stalwarts in the Indiana House of Representatives and Senate said that right to work would liberate both employers and the employed, creating a new gold rush of jobs and economic growth in the state. Over the fierce objections of Democrats and organized labor – union members came by the thousands to the Statehouse to protest – Republicans pushed the measure through.

John Krull, publisher,

John Krull, publisher,

In reality, the fight over right to work had little to do with jobs, economic growth or anything that in any way would have a positive effect on the state’s well-being.

The fight was about sandlot politics at the most immature level. The measure made it illegal to require employees to pay fees to a union to which they do not belong, even if they benefit from the negotiations and other services that union provides.

In short, it was a union-busting maneuver – one designed to strip organized labor, which generally supports Democrats, of funds.

Perhaps that’s why right to work’s backers began distancing themselves from their more extravagant promises almost as soon as the bill became law.

Almost as soon as then-Gov. Mitch Daniels, a Republican, had signed the measure into law, the Indiana Chamber of Commerce – which had orchestrated the symphony heralding the economic miracle that would be right to work when the bill was before the legislature – sent out an op-ed piece trying to lower expectations. Right to work wasn’t a panacea, the Chamber of Commerce said, and Hoosiers shouldn’t get their hopes up.

Republicans fell into line and issued similar statements about how Hoosiers shouldn’t misinterpret the fact that the GOP and the business community had spent months talking about how important right to work would be as a means of creating jobs as a promise that it actually would create, uh, jobs.

That raised the question of why Republicans pushed the state through the most divisive battle in modern memory if Hoosiers gained nothing from the outcome.

Now, a ruling from a Lake County judge likely will raise that question all over again.

A few days ago, Lake Superior Judge John Sedia – a Mitch Daniels appointee – ruled that right to work violates the Indiana Constitution because it requires unions to provide services without being paid for them. That violates a section of the Indiana Constitution that reads that “no person’s particular services shall be demanded, without just compensation.”

The judge’s ruling made a certain amount of sense, which may be why it provoked a strangely defensive response from state Republicans.

Right after the judge ruled, Indiana Senate President Pro Tem David Long, R-Fort Wayne, issued a statement that took issue with Sedia’s reasoning.

Long said that federal law should prevail when it comes to right to work – an odd argument for a state legislator to make, particularly one who has called for a new national constitutional convention to curb what the senator from Fort Wayne has called federal overreaching.

Long also offered what amounted to a mini legal brief about the ways Sedia had to be wrong that could be boiled down to one sentiment: The judge has to be wrong, because we Republicans will look pretty foolish if he isn’t.

Long is a smart guy – smart enough to know that arguments in court, rather than press releases, determine who wins or loses a legal battle. The fact that he felt compelled to issue a statement in support of the plausibility of right to work indicates some sensitivity to the wounds that fight produced that still have not healed.

We Hoosiers now are nearly three years into the right-to-work era. It’s been almost a year and a half since Republicans and the Chamber of Commerce “won” and the bill became law.

The fight in the sandlot still continues.

The promised jobs and economic growth have yet to arrive.

John Krull is director of Franklin College’s Pulliam School of Journalism, host of “No Limits” WFYI 90.1 FM Indianapolis and publisher of, a news website powered by Franklin College journalism students.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Share This Post